I was having issues with my State Industries (AO) water heater where I was having temperature fluctuations where some periods would be normal temperature (115-120) and other times tepid (95-105). Both heating elements had a good ohm measurement, but I decided to go ahead and replace both top and bottom heating elements and both upper and lower thermostats. After servicing my water heater, I have had consistent 115-120 temperatures. Been going 3 months and no issues yet. As long as the tank itself isn't compromised, I'm going to see how long I can keep the water heater in service.
The replacement can be a little tricky for first timers, in particular removing the old thermostat from the clip mechanism. Be sure to take a picture of the wires before swapping the thermostat so you reconnect the water heater properly. Shut of power at the circuit breaker and verify with a non-contact voltage tester before working on disconnecting the wires. Also, use some masking tape to hold the insulation out of the way while you work.
Kudos to supplyhouse.com for their one-stop selection of all my water heater parts. Would definitely buy from again!
VS
Most Liked Negative Review
Tends to get sloppy
I purchased this OEM unit because it snaps right into my AO Smith water heater. This is the second time I have replaced it in 3 years. If this one fails I will find another brand that will fit since this is the third set on this water heater. Both times the unit loses it's snap-action ability and gets real sloppy until there is 30-40 degrees of deadband between turning on and turning off. This eventually causes the top unit to trip on high temp.
Showing 1-10 of 50 reviews
Before you buy this, read the review
Before you buy this part, make sure the part you are replacing is the exact same size. I purchased this for my American Water Heater 80 gallon tank and it is too short. The wire from the top thermostat will not reach this unit since it is about a half inch shorter than the original part.
Use this part instead: 100110039
tlrthnu
MI
3 months ago
Was this review helpful to you?
Excellent buying experience
Great replacement thermostat. Clear installation instructions. No need to drain tank. Easy fix as first line effort to fix water heater.
Willem
Boston
5 months ago
Verified Buyer
Was this review helpful to you?
Exact Match Works Great
Exact match for existing AO Smith OEM Thermostat.
I'm Not A Plumber
FL
6 months ago
Verified Buyer
Was this review helpful to you?
Original AO Smith replacement product
Installed and works, this is a real AO Smith, and not "compatible" from China.
Krys
Boiling Springs, PA
6 months ago
Verified Buyer
Was this review helpful to you?
Water heater parts
Parts were all correct,called first and talked with lady she gave me part numbers .
Ted
Mn.
7 months ago
Verified Buyer
Was this review helpful to you?
Works
Easy to install; fixed the problem.
R
Earth
8 months ago
Verified Buyer
Was this review helpful to you?
Everything was perfect.
I installed the thermostats in the water heater. They were factory set at 120 degrees. Everything is working perfectly.
Guy
New Mexico
9 months ago
Verified Buyer
Was this review helpful to you?
Was it needed?
I replaced the top thermostat but didn't want to take any chances so I replaced this one also. Perfect fit.
robben
North Carolina
1 years ago
Verified Buyer
Was this review helpful to you?
400 Legend Ammo
Bought this ammo for my AR. Very fast, efficient delivery.
Lou G.
Bradenton, FL
2 years ago
Verified Buyer
Was this review helpful to you?
I would buy this product again!
Perfect replacement for original
Bud
Cincinnati, Ohio
2 years ago
Verified Buyer
Was this review helpful to you?
Free Shipping
On orders over $99
We offer flexible shipping and scheduling options, up-to-date delivery estimates, and free ground shipping on any order over $99 to make sure your order gets to you on-time, for less.
Ordered the wrong product? Item damaged in transit? Our 3-step process makes returning products easy – even up to a year after purchase – with no restocking fees on returns made within 90 days.